Gluten Free Monster Cookies Recipe

Indulge in scrumptious gluten free monster cookies with this simple and customizable recipe that both kids and adults will love. Packed with peanut butter, oats, and chocolate, these giant cookies are made without any rice flour or flour blend at all.

Whether you’re hosting a party, preparing a care package, or just satisfying a sweet craving, these naturally gluten free monster cookies will bring back memories—and create new ones!

What are monster cookies, anyway?

Monster cookies are basically just peanut butter cookies or oatmeal cookies with M&M chocolate candies and chocolate chips mixed in. They’re called “monster cookies” since they’re like the Frankenstein’s monster of cookies. All due respect to monsters. And cookies.

Are monster cookies gluten free?

Most monster cookie recipes have some all purpose flour added, along with oats, to help give them structure. It’s just like what you would do with traditional (gluten free) oatmeal cookies.

The best thing about baking cookies with oats and oat flour in them is that they have a really satisfying chew to them. That’s why our “Mrs. Fields” gluten free chocolate chip cookies have oats—and probably why they’re the most popular chocolate chip recipe on this site.

And that makes this recipe for monster cookies naturally gluten free, unlike almost every other recipe for monster cookies you’ll find—gluten free or not.

Why you’ll love these monster cookies (they really are the best)

The mixture of creamy peanut butter and sweet chocolate pieces in these cookies offers a delightful balance of flavors. Their versatility and customizability allow you to adapt the recipe to suit your preferences or cater to other dietary restrictions easily.

The hearty, chewy texture, derived from the clever use of old-fashioned rolled oats and oat flour, creates a satisfying and filling cookie.

Finally, the simple preparation method minimizes cleanup and makes the baking process a breeze. This convenience, combined with the mouthwatering taste and texture of these gluten-free monster cookies, guarantees that they will be a recipe you’ll return to time and time again.

The base is very similar to a classic gf oatmeal cookie, but since there’s no all purpose flour at all, it’s heartier and has more of the nutty, chewy flavor of oats.

The cookie is bound together with an egg, an egg yolk, and peanut butter. Along with old fashioned rolled oats and oat flour, the combination creates a chewy cookie that’s really stable (great for shipping in a care package!) and crispy on the outside.

The candy shell on the miniature chocolate M&Ms candies in these peanut butter oatmeal M&M cookies adds even more texture to these sweet chocolate chip cookies.

(All Purpose) Flourless Monster Cookies

I take flourless baking very seriously. Well, I mean not “seriously” like you would health or welfare, but I don’t use the term “flourless” lightly, is all.

When any grain or even nut is ground into a flour and used in the recipe, I don’t consider it truly flourless. But this recipe is rice flourless/all purpose flourless. All of my all purpose gluten free flour recipes are based on rice flour.

Key ingredients in GF monster cookies

• Old-fashioned rolled oats – Since these are gluten free monster cookies, we need to use so-called purity protocol gluten free old-fashioned rolled oats; they’re thin enough to chew, unlike steel cut oats, which must be soaked to eat
• Oat flour – I never buy gluten free oat flour; I just grind some of my old fashioned oats into oat flour in a blender; here, they help hold the cookie together without using a rice flour blend.
• Butter – Your butter should be at “room temperature,” which means that you can leave a fingerprint in it, but your finger doesn’t come away greasy
• Peanut butter – I love baking with no-stir smooth peanut butter, since it combines so well with other ingredients, much like room temperature butter does.
• Eggs – We use 1 whole egg for lift and as a binder, and 1 egg yolk, which helps soften the cookies’ texture (peanut butter tends to make baked goods crunchy)
• Light brown sugar – Light brown sugar has more moisture from the added molasses than granulated sugar; it tenderizes cookies and adds depth of flavor
• Semi-sweet chocolate chips – Some people make monster cookies with regular size M&Ms, but I really prefer semi-sweet chocolate chips.
• Miniature M&Ms – Miniature M&Ms are small enough to mix throughout the cookie dough without overpowering the cookie, and there’s extra candy shell for more texture.

Baking gluten free monster cookies with oats and oat flour

Baking with oats (which can be substituted in all my baking, if you’re unable or unwilling to eat them!) can be tricky, though. Old fashioned rolled oats, which are one of the least processed forms of oats, are relatively thick.

One way to make a stable cookie that holds together is to add a rice flour blend to it. But in this gluten free chocolate chip monster cookies recipe, I simply ground some old fashioned rolled oats into a flour and added that to the recipe. Oats are simple to grind into a flour in a blender or food processor.

The rest of the oats in this recipe are more like quick-cooking oats. But I’m too cheap to ever buy oats any more processed than old-fashioned oats, so I just pulse old-fashioned oats a few times in a food processor. And I call them quick-cooking oats.

The result is an amazingly chewy oatmeal cookie with a satisfying peanut butter-chocolate flavor. They rise and spread evenly to make these giant monster cookies a real treat.

How to make these gluten free monster cookies cookies

Whenever possible, I try to make cake batter and cookie dough in one single bowl. I find that it’s not often necessary to beat butter, sugar, and eggs separately unless you’re making a delicate vanilla cake, for example.

In this recipe, though, I prefer to mix the dry ingredients (oat flour, oats, baking soda and salt) in a separate bowl first. I find that it’s easiest to get all the lumps out of the brown sugar by mixing it with the butter, peanut butter, eggs, and vanilla separately. You don’t need a hand or stand mixer to do that job, although you could certainly use one.

The oat and oat flour mixture is then added to the wet ingredients and mixed just to combine. When baking with oat flour especially, the baked goods can become tough if you work the batter or dough too hard. This way, the oats can be handled much less when everything is combined.

If you would really prefer to make this recipe in one bowl, you can whisk together the dry ingredients in a large bowl, create a well in the center of the dry ingredients and add the wet ingredients (butter, peanut butter, egg mixture, vanilla, and sugar).

Then, mix until combined, but try not to overmix. Add the chips and candies, and mix gently to combine.

Tips for making the best gluten free monster cookies

This recipe is so easy, it’s difficult to get wrong. But, there are a few quick tips that ensure your gluten free monster cookies are the best they can be.

Use an ice cream scoop for easy portioning

Right after the dough is assembled, scoop large rounded balls of dough using a spring-loaded ice cream scoop that’s packed tight to help create a round shape. If you have trouble getting the cookie dough out of the scooper, rinse it with warm water in between scoops.

Use no-stir peanut butter for better results

Truly all natural peanut butter that requires stirring is usually too oily for baking, and tends to separate in the cookie dough. No-stir peanut butter has emulsifiers that keep the oil mixed in to the nut butter.

Use parchment paper for quick cleanup

Line your baking sheets and pans with parchment paper to ensure even baking, and to make cleanup a breeze. I keep and reuse sheets of parchment multiple times, to avoid so much waste.

Making gluten free monster cookie dough in advance

You can make this gluten free monster cookie dough ahead of time, as long as you shape the balls of cookie dough right after you make the mixture. As the cookie dough sits, the oils get more fully absorbed into the flours, and the dough may not hold together as well. Just shape the cookie dough balls, then cover the portions and you can bake it hours later.

Refrigerating gluten free monster cookies dough

If you’d like to make the monster cookie dough farther in advance, you can refrigerate the shaped portions for 2 to 3 days. Be sure to cover them first so they don’t dry out, and allow the cookie dough to come to room temperature before baking.

Freezing gluten free monster cookies dough

For longer storage, try flash freezing the dough balls on a baking sheet in a single layer. Transfer them to a zip-top bag for longer storage. To ensure that the cookies spread properly, let them come to room temperature before baking.

How to store monster cookies

Monster cookies are really stable and stay fresh for days in a sealed glass container at room temperature. Don’t store them in a plastic container at room temperature, or they’ll lose their crisp exterior and become more fragile.

Freezing baked monster cookies

You can freeze these baked monster cookies in a freezer safe zip-top bag and enjoy them right from the freezer, or warmed up a bit in the microwave or on the counter. Squeeze as much air as possible out of the bag to avoid freezer burn.

Substitutions for gluten free monster cookies ingredients

These crisp-outside, chewy inside cookies have a fair number of additional allergens in them. Here are my best guesses for how to avoid them.

Please keep in mind that this recipe was formulated to work precisely as written. The more substitutions you make, the more you are veering toward a separate recipe entirely.

Gluten free dairy-free monster cookies

The only dairy in these cookies is from the unsalted butter and the M&Ms chocolate candies. The M&Ms can easily be replaced with more chocolate chips, and you can of course use dairy-free semi-sweet chocolate chips.

I haven’t tried replacing the butter, but you should be able to use Melt or Miyoko’s Kitchen brand vegan butter. I don’t generally like Earth Balance buttery sticks because they have so much moisture which will likely cause the cookies to spread too much during baking.

You can also try replacing the butter with virgin coconut oil. It’s the type that’s solid at cool room temperature.

Are M&Ms chocolate candies gluten free?

If you live in the U.S., most plain varieties of M&Ms chocolate candies are gluten free. I do understand that if you’re in Australia, M&Ms aren’t gluten free. Just use miniature chocolate chips or even raisins!

Gluten free egg-free monster cookies

The single whole egg in this recipe should be able to be replaced with 1 “chia egg” (1 tablespoon ground white chia seeds + 1 tablespoon lukewarm water, mixed and allowed to gel).

The egg yolk is in the recipe for moisture, so you can try replacing it with about a tablespoon or so of smooth applesauce. I’m afraid you’ll just have to experiment!

Monster cookies without peanut butter

If you need to make this recipe without peanuts, I’m sure a similar style of almond butter (like Barney Butter) would work great. I also have a recipe for Nutella monster cookies that is peanut-free.

If you need the recipe to be nut-free, you can try replacing the nut butter with Wowbutter, made with toasted soy nuts, which seems nice and creamy. You could also try sunflower seed butter, but your cookies may spread more, and they may even turn a harmless green color when mixed with baking soda.

Monster cookies without oatmeal

In baking, oat flour can often be replaced with quinoa flakes, and old-fashioned oats can be replaced with beaten rice or sometimes coconut flakes/chips.

More delicious mix-ins for gf monster cookies

• For even more peanut flavor, try replacing some of the mix-ins with chopped roasted peanuts or other chopped nuts.
• Swap in white chocolate chips instead of some or all of the semi-sweet chocolate chips.
• Add crushed mini gluten free pretzel twists or sticks instead of some of the chocolate chips or mini M&Ms

FAQs

Is there gluten in monster cookies?

If monster cookies are made with conventional all purpose flour, they will contain wheat. This recipe is made without all purpose flour of any kind, and with gluten free oats and oat flour, so it’s completely gluten free.

What sort of peanut butter works best in this monster cookies recipe?

I specify “no-stir”, regular creamy peanut butter in this recipe, as I do in most recipes that I write that contain peanut butter as an ingredient. All “no-stir” means is that the oil in the jar of peanut butter doesn’t separate significantly from the rest of the nut butter in the jar.

Most commercially prepared peanut butter is no-stir. My favorite brand is Skippy, since it’s great-tasting, always smooth, and all varieties of Skippy are gluten free. but I also sometimes use Barney Butter—although it tends to be quite expensive. Even Skippy “Natural” peanut butter says on the outside that there’s “no need to stir.”

Can I use crunchy peanut butter for this gf monster cookies recipe?

Chunky peanut butter doesn’t mix in quite as well as smooth peanut butter in this recipe, so I’d avoid using it in this recipe. Stick with the creamy smooth peanut butter, and replace some of the chips or mini M&Ms with some chopped peanuts for a nutty crunch if you’d like that.

Are oats gluten free?

In the U.S., there are certified gluten free oats that are grown on dedicated gluten-free fields and stored in dedicated silos. Some people who are gluten intolerant are also intolerant to oats, and so they should avoid them.

What’s the difference between old-fashioned oats and quick oats?

As I note in the recipe below, I never buy oats that are more processed than old-fashioned rolled oats, since quick oats are just slightly more processed old-fashioned rolled oats.

What are the best oats for this monster cookies recipe?

For oats, I only buy purity protocol gluten free old fashioned rolled oats, which are made in dedicated fields and processed on dedicated equipment, so they’re free of cross-contamination.

For oat flour, I simply grind them in a blender or food processor as finely as possible. For quick-cooking oats, I process them very quickly with just a few pulses in a food processor (a blender tends to grind oats into flour completely).

Why did my monster cookies without flour come out flat?

If your butter was melted or oily because it was too warm, your cookies may spread too much and come out flat.

How to make gluten free monster cookies, step by step (below)